Welcome to Pithari
At Pithari, situated in the heart of Middletown, DE, a culinary journey through the Mediterranean awaits you. This captivating restaurant, housed in a historic building, masterfully combines a warm ambiance with exceptional service. Pithari takes pride in its carefully crafted menu, featuring exquisite appetizers like burrata and Moroccan shrimp, as well as house-made flatbreads and artisanal pasta. Each dish resonates with vibrant flavors and fresh ingredients, ensuring a memorable dining experience. The lively atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for special occasions or casual meals, leaving diners eager to return for another taste of Mediterranean delight.
-
1 W Main St, Middletown, DE 19709 Hotline: (302) 570-7600
Welcome to Pithari, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Middletown, Delaware, at 1 W Main St. This Mediterranean-inspired restaurant offers an exquisite dining experience that harmonizes tradition with modern flair.
At Pithari, the menu is a delightful canvas of flavors, featuring a range of flatbreads, pastas, and appetizers that are thoughtfully crafted to tantalize your taste buds. The flatbreads are a must-try, with standout options like the Tartufata—an indulgent concoction of truffle cream, provolone cheese, and prosciutto, finished with a delicate sherry vinaigrette—and the Blue Fig, a sweet and savory blend of fig jam, caramelized onions, and blue cheese.
Moving on to the pastas, you are treated to hand-cut masterpieces. The Pappardelle Al Manzo is a dish of slow-braised beef in a rich red wine reduction, while the Seafood Linguine delivers a taste of the ocean with its medley of jumbo shrimp, scallops, and mussels nestled in a fragrant seafood broth.
The appetizers are equally impressive, with items like the Whipped Ricotta served with charred eggplant salad, and Diver Scallops that evoke a sense of luxury—each bite artfully accompanied by truffle parsnip cream. Customers rave about the Moroccan Shrimp, where fried shrimp meets a zesty lemon turmeric cream, creating a dish that lingers in memory long after the last bite.
The restaurant's ambiance deserves a mention of its own. Many patrons, like Jamal L. and Kate C., appreciate not only the quality of the food but also the warm and inviting atmosphere. With attentive staff who are knowledgeable and keenly aware of your dining needs, the service complements the high standards of the cuisine.
When it comes to dessert, Pithari does not disappoint. The Crème Brûlée Cheesecake and Apple Tartine have become favorites among guests, and it’s easy to see why. Each dessert is crafted with care, ensuring the sweet ending is as memorable as the meal itself.
In what could be described as an ode to upscale Mediterranean dining, Pithari stands out not only for its exceptional menu but also for its commitment to providing an excellent dining experience. Whether celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, this restaurant promises to nurture your culinary desires and exceeds expectations.
For an ambiance that melds history with modernity and a menu that celebrates flavor, Pithari is not just a meal but an experience worth savoring. Reservations are highly recommended, so don’t miss your chance to delve into what this charming establishment has to offer.
Contact Information:
Location: 1 W Main St, Middletown, DE 19709
Phone: (302) 570-7600
I wanted to wait until a sit down visit, but after several takeout meals, I have to write a review. Each meal has been delicious! So far I've had the Moroccan Shrimp, Blue Fig Flatbread, Seafood Linguine, Branzino Al Forno, Chicken Kebab, Creme Brûlée Cheesecake, Apple Tartine. Everything has been exceptional. For takeout to be so consistently good, I can only imagine how great the dining experience must be.
Great place to have a birthday dinner or brunch. Loved the atmosphere however, we did have an emergency situation where a family member choked on her chicken and waffles. I would recommend more tender chicken to serve. On the upside the staff reacted quickly and we still somehow managed to make the best of the time.
From ambiance to service to the food, this restaurant checks all the boxes. The food was phenomenal and the playing was done with care and attention. We had the Greek salad with chicken, which was delicious. While we didn't love the wheat barley base, we ate around it, which was delicious. The fig flat bread had layers of flavor and texture, and the tiramisu was absolute perfection. I can't recommend this restaurant enough.
We had the best experience here celebrating our anniversary. Our server, Lauren was incredibly helpful and attentive the entire time and the ambience of the restaurant was stunning. We ordered the Brussel sprouts, the burrata, and the shrimp to start and each were incredible! The Brussel sprouts were really outstanding! For our mains, we got the chicken skewer and the tagliatelle. Both were phenomenal! Perfectly seasoned and incredibly satiating. We ended our meal with the crème brûlée cheesecake and it was perfectly decadent. All of the food was perfect! The drinks maintained that level of perfection and each one that we had was refreshing and delicious! The cosmopolitan was quite the experience with the smoke bubble presentation! We literally can't wait to go back to the gem of a restaurant!
Fabulous total experience. Setting was great, food was amazing. Staff were attentive and knowledgable. If you have an opportunity to go, take it!
Amazing place!!! We had no reservation but were seated promptly. Thankful. The staff was friendly and quickly removed items on tables as soon as we were done with each item. The food was delicious!!! Tasted as good as the food I ate in Greece!! The restaurant was decorated for Valentine's Day. Very nice. Highly recommend this spot. I will be back, hopefully soon!!!
Excellent service, beautiful restaurant and the food was amazing. We had the pappardelle and seafood linguine with chicken skewers as an appetizer. Shared the crème brûlée cheesecake for dessert. Is was DELICIOUS Would highly recommend!
A bit of Middletown historical tidbit, the building in which this restaurant resides in used to be the Wachovia Bank. During the Great Financial Crisis ( 2008 ), Wells Fargo took over Wachovia, and relocated its branch to Dove Run Plaza instead. Pithari is the second rendition of revitalizing this building into a high end dining venue. The interior is well decorated, with no signs of previous function. The menu is limited, with the selections of appetizers outnumbered the main entrees options. However, all entrees ordered were well prepared and presented. Pricing reflects that of high end dining, but reasonable when compared with others in the area. Staff was friendly, and attentive to our needs. So if you have a special occasion, this would be a good place to celebrate in.
All was excellent. Great environment and amazing, tasty food We had a fantastic experience! As soon as we arrived we were greeted and seated. Received immediate attention and quick got our drinks. Appetizers were promptly served to perfection. Meals were also very tasty and met our expectations. Would certainly return to share this place with others.